Positively Fifth Street

asked by vern on November 14, 2006 3:59 PM

In 2000, novelist and poet James McManus was sent to Las Vegas, innocently enough, by Harper's magazine to write a story about the World Series of Poker held annually at Binion's Horseshoe. But then, as so often happens on trips to Sin City, something kind of ... happened. Rather than becoming an objective report, McManus's article evolved into a memoir as he put his entire advance on the line, got lucky with his cards and won a spot in the competition, and came much closer than anyone expected to winning the darn thing. The result, Positively Fifth Street, is just as dazzling, exciting, and disturbing as Vegas itself.

McManus details his battles not only against his opponents but also against "Bad Jim," the portion of his own personality that needs to get in on a poker game in spite of both common and fiscal sense. Besides telling his own story, he relates the considerably more unpleasant tale of Ted Binion, whose grisly death was blamed on Binion's former stripper-girlfriend and her ex-linebacker beau. In the hands of a lesser author, the pursuit of these separate through lines of poker and the seedy personal lives of wealthy casino heirs may have lead readers to wish the author had picked just one subject. But under McManus's careful watch, they're really pretty similar: steeped in adrenaline, mystery, deception, and skating on thrillingly thin ice. Each story underscores the other, a neat little "narrative as metaphor" device, while also painting a vivid picture of Vegas casino life. Poker, as anyone who has lost at it will tell you, is an intricate game and it's nice to see a top-notch author and player relate its finer points in an entertaining style that will appeal even to non-players. The author's hilariously self-aware and at times self-loathing style make Positively Fifth Street a fun read. But beyond that, his account of nearly winning the biggest poker tournament in the world and subsequently watching as the verdicts are announced for Binion's accused murderers makes for a great story. Even if it wasn't the one he was sent there to write. --John Moe

Buy this book

[report to moderator]

Reviews

As both a writer and a poker player myself, I found this book to be absolutely the most engaging thing I've read in quite some time. From the first page, McManus grabs the reader's attention and doesn't let go. I know of few other places where a reader can get such a smorgasbord of scintillating subjects: steamy sex/money scandals, murder, courtroom drama, Vegas politics, the psycho-sexual nuances of poker, a history of gambling, Sylvia Plath, and the most thrilling, edge-of-your seat account of a sporting event (albeit poker) that I've ever read. I loved every page and hated to finish it. The only negative thing I can say is that I'm jealous--I wish I'd written it!

reviewed by bigwinner on November 19, 2006 1:50 AM

[report to moderator]

As another reviewer said in his 1-star review of this book, the sections on poker are excellent but they are buried inside of seemingly endless chapters on Ted Binion's murder, the author's grandparents, and all kinds of other nonsense. While those subjects could possibly be fascinating, McManus isn't nearly good enough as a writer to make them interesting. So what we're left with is a highly-compelling description of the 2000 WSOP for about 1/3rd of the book and then 2/3rds garbage.

Best avoided if you're looking for a poker book.

reviewed by runaway on November 20, 2006 5:06 PM

[report to moderator]

This book was written before no limit Texas Hold 'Em became the rage everywhere. The author does a good job of explaining the game and following Binion's World Series of Poker while covering a sensational murder trial. Some readers will enjoy as well digressions on the history of card playing and so forth. My only wish is that his prose was more vivid and exciting--it's a great topic but a little more of a Hunter S. Thompson fear and loathing bite would make it a superb book.

reviewed by onthemic on November 21, 2006 7:27 PM

[report to moderator]

add a new book!