Me Talk Pretty One Day this question feed

asked by alexis on November 11, 2006 7:19 PM
David Sedaris became a star autobiographer on public radio, onstage in New York, and on bestseller lists, mostly on the strength of "SantaLand Diaries," a scathing, hilarious account of his stint as a Christmas elf at Macy's. (It's in two separate collections, both worth owning, Barrel Fever and the Christmas-themed Holidays on Ice.) Sedaris's caustic gift has not deserted him in his fourth book, which mines poignant comedy from his peculiar childhood in North Carolina, his bizarre career path, and his move with his lover to France. Though his anarchic inclination to digress is his glory, Sedaris does have a theme in these reminiscences: the inability of humans to communicate. The title is his rendition in transliterated English of how he and his fellow students of French in Paris mangle the Gallic language. In the essay "Jesus Shaves," he and his classmates from many nations try to convey the concept of Easter to a Moroccan Muslim. "It is a party for the little boy of God," says one. "Then he be die one day on two... morsels of... lumber," says another. Sedaris muses on the disputes between his Protestant mother and his father, a Greek Orthodox guy whose Easter fell on a different day. Other essays explicate his deep kinship with his eccentric mom and absurd alienation from his IBM-exec dad: "To me, the greatest mystery of science continues to be that a man could father six children who shared absolutely none of his interests."

Every glimpse we get of Sedaris's family and acquaintances delivers laughs and insights. He thwarts his North Carolina speech therapist ("for whom the word pen had two syllables") by cleverly avoiding all words with s sounds, which reveal the lisp she sought to correct. His midget guitar teacher, Mister Mancini, is unaware that Sedaris doesn't share his obsession with breasts, and sings "Light My Fire" all wrong--"as if he were a Webelo scout demanding a match." As a remarkably unqualified teacher at the Art Institute of Chicago, Sedaris had his class watch soap operas and assign "guessays" on what would happen in the next day's episode.

It all adds up to the most distinctively skewed autobiography since Spalding Gray's Swimming to Cambodia. The only possible reason not to read this book is if you'd rather hear the author's intrinsically funny speaking voice narrating his story. In that case, get Me Talk Pretty One Day on audio. --Tim Appelo


Reviews

Thumb_up
Thumb_down

0%
0%
Suffice it to say that Sedaris is not to everyone's taste. However, you would have to be pretty humorless not to appreciate his unique perspective on subjects as diverse as his family and his experiences as a not-so-innocent abroad in France who initially has no interest in learning the language--then six years into his French experience, finally takes on the mother tongue with all he has--which he is quick to admit isn't much.

A lot of fun, and if you're having a tough personal time, Sedaris will show you how much better off you are than he is! (But really, the man's a best-seller, so he can't be too bad!)

If your humor goes a little left of center, this is a good read for you.
reviewed by bricktop on November 21, 2006 2:59 PM

Thumb_up
Thumb_down

0%
0%
I'd heard great things about this book, especially how hysterically funny the author is. I suppose his humor just isn't my style. Many of the stories were mean and made his family out to be grotesque beyond belief. Perhaps David Sedaris' family is accurately portrayed here, but I find that hard to swallow.

My major problem with this book was the tone of the narration; Sedaris seems so self-satisfied, and in my opinion he thinks he is much wittier than he really is. This attitude came through in his stories and was a real turnoff to me.

However, some of the things he wrote did make me laugh and won me over to some degree. I don't find Sedaris a brilliant comic writer, but I don't feel my time reading his book was completely wasted.
reviewed by blueoasis on November 28, 2006 6:38 AM

Thumb_up
Thumb_down

0%
0%
and then when i read to her what i was laughing at, she laughed right along with me.
these essays are pure genius. sedaris really knows how to put his thoughts together and not once did i say "what the hell is he talking about??"
although a few of the bits might be sad to some, thankfully i have the dark sarcastic humor that sedaris requires of his readers.
he is one of my idols.
the essays are different yet tie in together perfectly.
reviewed by webster on November 28, 2006 1:41 PM

search

 
 

browse

book tags