Black Hawk Down: A Story of Modern War 
asked by maxmill on November 5, 2006 10:15 AM
Journalist Mark Bowden delivers a strikingly detailed account of the 1993 nightmare operation in Mogadishu that left 18 American soldiers dead and many more wounded. This early foreign-policy disaster for the Clinton administration led to the resignation of Secretary of Defense Les Aspin and a total troop withdrawal from Somalia. Bowden does not spend much time considering the context; instead he provides a moment-by-moment chronicle of what happened in the air and on the ground. His gritty narrative tells of how Rangers and elite Delta Force troops embarked on a mission to capture a pair of high-ranking deputies to warlord Mohamed Farrah Aidid only to find themselves surrounded in a hostile African city. Their high-tech MH-60 Black Hawk helicopters had been shot down and a number of other miscues left them trapped through the night. Bowden describes Mogadishu as a place of Mad Max-like anarchy--implying strongly that there was never any peace for the supposed peacekeepers to keep. He makes full use of the defense bureaucracy's extensive paper trail--which includes official reports, investigations, and even radio transcripts--to describe the combat with great accuracy, right down to the actual dialogue. He supplements this with hundreds of his own interviews, turning Black Hawk Down into a completely authentic nonfiction novel, a lively page-turner that will make readers feel like they're standing beside the embattled troops. This will quickly be realized as a modern military classic. --John J. Miller
Reviews
Having seen the movie numerous times and believing it to be the ultimate war/anti-war film, I decided to read the novel on which the movie was based. I was not disappointed because the novel seems to create a movie in ones brain and you find yourself in the boots of those young men fighting for their lives. It is a novel about a brotherhood of soliders who when placed in a desperate situation had only each other to rely on. It also is a story about how a super power that put men on the Moon and circled Mars with a space vehicle, couldn't direct a convoy of vehicles a matter of yards. A tremendous read and given our situation in Iraq, a very topical story.
reviewed by jazzman on November 22, 2006 7:57 PM
A good book and story that needed to told, the movie can lets you see the action better, but book makes you see the men as heroes.
reviewed by goonball on November 23, 2006 12:34 PM
It should come as no news flash that this is a fine piece of journalism. After you've read it, which shouldn't take long, you might think that you blasted out of Mogadishu with Delta Force on the "Day of the Rangers".
Beyond the entertainment value, BHD will help provide context to the current events happening in Somalia.
I also highly recommend Bowden's "Killing Pablo".
Beyond the entertainment value, BHD will help provide context to the current events happening in Somalia.
I also highly recommend Bowden's "Killing Pablo".
reviewed by librarian on November 28, 2006 6:11 PM
Blackhawk Down follows the harrowing story of a two-day battle that took place in the remote town of Mogadishu in October '93. The description of the Americans and the Somali people is detailed and interesting. It is amazing to read how an actual battle took place. The book is full of gore and human suffering, which proved to be a real eye-opener for me. This is probably the most violent book I've ever read (or in my case listened to), but the message is powerful. Out there beyond our country we have soldiers fighting battles we might not even be aware of, but the battles are important nonetheless. Lives are important and we have soldiers risking theirs that we may live ours. My respect for the military went up several notches after experiencing this book.
I listened to this in audio book format. I couldn't find it being sold on Amazon so maybe it isn't available anymore. Still, I'm going to have to say this is probably a better book to read than listen to. The violent descriptions and the frequent use of the F-bomb doesn't make for the happiest of listening. Not to mention the man who voiced the book sounded robotic. I didn't really feel emotionally tied to anyone until near the end probably due to the passionless drone of the guy reading it. Also with all the different soldiers it was hard to keep up with their names, something that would most likely be easier if I'd just picked it up and read it.
I listened to this in audio book format. I couldn't find it being sold on Amazon so maybe it isn't available anymore. Still, I'm going to have to say this is probably a better book to read than listen to. The violent descriptions and the frequent use of the F-bomb doesn't make for the happiest of listening. Not to mention the man who voiced the book sounded robotic. I didn't really feel emotionally tied to anyone until near the end probably due to the passionless drone of the guy reading it. Also with all the different soldiers it was hard to keep up with their names, something that would most likely be easier if I'd just picked it up and read it.
reviewed by versed on November 28, 2006 11:33 PM
Mr. Bowden is one of the greatest authors dealing with documentaries on this subject. Again, he descibes in detail what happened on the ground on that dreadful operation and soldiers that read this can clearly see the lessons learned in comparison to modern day operations. Mr. Bowdens ability to describe in articulate detail gives the reader the twisted feeling of actually being shot at without the rounds whizzing by your head. I truly couldnt put this book down!!!!
reviewed by webster on November 28, 2006 11:43 PM
